How Disparate Impact Is Hurting Office Diversity

Story shared by :Adebimpe Adeogun
6 days ago| 8 min read
Restart Audio
Play Audio
Play
Restart

Maybe you've been there. You hit every target, you trained the new hires, and you stayed late more times than you can count. When the promotion finally opened up, it went to someone else, and the reason you were given was so vague you couldn't argue with it. You were told you weren't "quite ready yet." You went home that evening wondering what more you could have done.

That feeling is familiar to more people than you might think. It is familiar to women, to people of colour, to disabled employees, to older workers and to anyone who has ever sensed that the rules at work were written with someone else in mind. It is easy to blame yourself. Sometimes, though, the problem is not you at all. It lies in the workplace rules themselves, and this is what's known as disparate impact.

Disparate impact happens when a workplace rule applies to everyone but still hurts some groups more than others. Imagine a company that only promotes people who have worked there for ten years without a break. On paper, everyone is held to the same standard. In practice, many parents who took time off to raise children are left out, and so are people who had to step away because of illness or disability. No one at the company set out to exclude them, but that is how the rule plays out.

Where the Idea Came From

The idea took legal shape in 1971, when the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on Griggs v. Duke Power Co. Duke Power required workers to have a high school diploma and pass a standardised test before they could move into better-paying roles. The company had no proof that a diploma or a test score said anything about how well someone would do the job. As a result, fully capable Black workers never got the chance to do the work. The court ruled that discrimination doesn't depend on intent. If a neutral policy keeps disadvantaging a protected group without a real business reason, that is enough.

Disparate Impact vs. Disparate Treatment

Disparate treatment is deliberate, as when a manager turns someone down because of their race, gender, age, disability or another protected trait. Because it is intentional, it is usually easier to spot and challenge. Disparate impact is harder to confront because the person making the decision may have no bias at all. The rule itself causes the harm each time it is applied, so there is often no single person to hold responsible.

As AllVoices explains, disparate impact concerns the unintended effects of a practice rather than anyone's motives. Many organisations struggle with this. They assume that if no one meant to cause harm, then no harm was done. Yet the employee who keeps getting passed over is affected just the same, whatever anyone intended.

What It Looks Like in Practice

Most of the time, disparate impact hides inside rules that seem perfectly sensible. Think about a job that asks for a four-year degree when the work doesn't call for one. A first-generation worker who taught himself every skill the role needs might scroll past the listing because he assumes it isn't meant for him. A single mother who left university to support her family might do the same. Neither of them applies, so the company misses out on two people who could have done the job well.

AI hiring tools can cause the same problem on a much larger scale. A tool trained on past hiring decisions picks up the biases in them and may screen out qualified candidates from groups that were overlooked before. That could be someone whose name suggests a particular background, an older applicant with a long work history, or a disabled candidate with a gap in their employment.

Promotions can be affected too. When moving up depends on visibility, personal connections or a manager's sense of someone's "potential," the people who can stay for after-work drinks or catch the boss in the corridor tend to get ahead. A parent who leaves on time to collect their children, an employee who works remotely to manage a health condition, or someone who doesn't share the same background as the people in charge may be doing work that is just as good but get noticed far less.

The Human Cost Behind the Statistics

The person from the start of this article is not one unlucky employee. Their experience shows up clearly in the data, especially for people who face more than one kind of disadvantage. McKinsey and LeanIn.org's 2025 Women in the Workplace report found that women remain underrepresented at every level of corporate America and hold only 29% of C-suite roles, with women of colour holding around 7%. For every 100 men promoted to manager, 93 women are promoted. That number falls to 82 for Asian women and Latinas, and to just 60 for Black women.

Sponsorship follows a similar pattern. The report found that 45% of entry-level men have a sponsor, compared with 31% of women. A sponsor is someone senior who speaks up for you and puts you forward for opportunities. That kind of support matters most early in a career, which is exactly where the gap between men and women is widest.

These numbers describe real people who are being held back at different points in their careers. It doesn't happen all at once but through one missed opportunity after another, so the gap grows slowly and often goes unnoticed. Many only see it years later, when they look around and realise that people who joined at the same time as them are now two levels ahead.

As HerConversation explored in "The Price of Gender Bias: Why Women Are Still Underpaid," old ideas about who belongs where can find their way into everyday workplace systems through unconscious bias. When those systems work in your favour, they tend to look fair, but they feel very different to the people they keep leaving out.

Why It Is So Hard to See From the Inside

Most people running these systems believe they are rewarding merit. A hiring manager who insists on a degree thinks they are keeping standards high, and a manager who promotes the most visible person on the team thinks they are recognising good work. Neither of them is likely to look back and ask who keeps missing out.

When someone does question a decision, the answer usually comes back to the person rather than the process. She wasn't quite ready, he wasn't the right fit, or the timing was off. Because hardly anyone looks at how the decision was made, the employee is left wondering what they did wrong, and after hearing the same kind of feedback again and again, many begin to doubt their own abilities.

The Legal Landscape Has Shifted

For a long time, the law pushed organisations to take an honest look at their policies. In April 2025, an executive order told federal agencies to step back from enforcing disparate impact rules, following earlier moves that rolled back DEI programmes in many sectors.

The order doesn't change the law for private employers, and employees can still take a case to court themselves. Critics warn, however, that without the federal government stepping in, it will be much harder to challenge policies that keep producing unequal results, especially when no one can prove the unfairness was intentional. That leaves people who already struggle to be treated fairly at work with less support than before, and it means companies that care about fairness will now have to review their own policies without anyone telling them to.

What Needs to Change

The first step is for organisations to look at what their policies actually do to people, rather than what they were designed to do. They can start by asking which job requirements really matter for the role and which have stayed in place simply because no one has questioned them. AI hiring tools should be tested for bias before they are used, since a tool trained on biased data will repeat that bias with every application it screens. Promotions should follow clear, written criteria, so that a person's chances don't depend on how comfortable their manager feels around them. Companies should also keep track of who gets hired, who gets promoted, and who leaves. They should integrate this data by race, gender, age, and disability, because those numbers will tell them far more about their workplace than any values statement.

Conclusion

Disparate impact is one of the main reasons inequality lasts in organisations that would never describe themselves as discriminatory. A company can have good intentions and still treat people unfairly, and a new programme or updated policy won't fix that unless someone looks closely at what is really happening and acts on it.

If you have ever been told you weren't ready when you knew you were, you had good reason to feel frustrated. The rules you were measured against may never have been designed with people like you in mind. Knowing this can help you stop blaming yourself, and it shows workplaces where the real problems lie.

Comments

User

More Authors

Dive into HerVerse

Subscribe to HerConversation’s newsletter and elevate your dialogue

@ 2025 All Rights Reserved.

@ 2025 All Rights Reserved.